BIRTHDAYS AND WHY SURVIVOR PHILS. MIGHT NOT WORK FOR US

I’ve never really had a more blissful birthday than the day I turned 23. It’s not so much the idea of having to celebrate it simply. It’s because I felt that I’ve become a much more different person (for the better?), as inspired by my sheer desire to change the moment I turned a year older.

PS: To all the people who sent their birthday greetings before, during and after my birthday, I could never fully express my appreciation for all of you. Some of you even surprised me. That alone makes the day even more special than I ever thought it would be. Merci.

+++

While I was rummaging the Internet for some Survivor Gabon updates, the country’s own version of the reality TV show come to mind (BTW, when will it officially air? Anyone?) Now, I’m not exactly all flaps about the local version even though I’m a super fan of the American show. But I think that there are  factors why Survivor Philippines might fail to be as fun and as exciting as its predecessor.

Here are my matter-of-fact reasons:

1. Pinoys are ultra sensitive.

Survivor is about outwitting, outplaying and outlasting fellow castaways in the game. Yes, it’s also about magically making the most of life in a deserted island, since there’ll be no food or any other form of luxury out there. For this part, I think Pinoys can stand the test of time. We are, after all, one of the most tried and tested nationalities in the world.

But the other side of the game is what I am cynic about. The game is basically screwing each other in the end to win. Dealing with strangers is one thing. Betraying them is another.

Judging by the common Pinoy’s emotional threshold, I don’t think most of them can handle a game like Survivor, especially when emotions usually run high in the latter part of the show. Of course, friendships naturally form in the process and we as a people usually give utmost importance to that. We’d dodge a bullet for a friend, even give up a lot of money for them. Too much righteousness , gullibility and trust can be the boon of any Filipino survivor, IMHO. Moreover, most Pinoys take high regard of utang na loob and palabra de honor so it’s gonna be hard to overcome all these moral standards, and get by in the wilderness at the same time.

Lying, cheating and stabbing each other in the back are a norm in Survivor. The Pinoy moral compass shall be seriously conflicted. I don’t think Pinoys can understand the phrase, “it’s all part of the game” when they prioritize maintaining friendships along the way. And once you lied in the game, even if it’s the smartest thing to do strategy-wise, you’ll be branded a liar forever in Philippine society. And that’ll be harder to overcome.

Hey, I still hope I’m wrong about this.

2. Majority of Pinoys still squirm at the sight of nudity.

Part of the game is having a strategy to take yourself at least in the Final Four. So, everyone should be good at people dynamics and politics as a whole. Most men and women, who have the resources to be “visually stimulating,” usually do certain things to flaunt them so these resources can work to their advantage. The American castaways definitely succeeded in that (especially when there’s peanut butter and chocolate at stake. LOL) and even condoned such acts because it’s entertaining. For them, that is. However, in our local version, a little implication of any nudity or sexual display would leave MTRCB people and other conservatists up on their heels.

And then we’ll say, “here we go again…”

3. Too much drama.

I’m sure Filipinos would play the “poverty” card given that most people (including their American counterparts) all play to win the pot money. I don’t have anything against that. I just hope that it wouldn’t be the be-all and end-all of the show, focusing on people’s needs as to who deserves to win rather than analyzing each other’s gameplay to make it to the top.

Like any Survivor installments, the show should focus on the game itself. How strangers, from different walks of life, survive with each other, create relationships and eventually fight with each other to claim the million bucks.A little drama won’t hurt, but please, not all the time!

Heck, even ex-NFL quarterbacks, a rocket scientist, an astronaut, a marketing executive and a swimsuit model survived without getting voted out early just because they are a little bit better on the financial side.

Or, a hearing-impaired contestant and people with prosthetic legs made it further than any other “normal” people in the game. Not because they are at  a disadvantage so they’re playing the sympathy card, but because they either aligned with the right people or performed well in challenges.

Hence, all is fair in love, war and Survivor.

4. An episode a day keeps the audience away.

What’s good about weekly Survivor servings is that there’s room for anticipation. Airing Survivor Philippines on a daily basis (obviously) only means GMA 7 is a ratings monger and I don’t know if they could really draw the line between what is good and what sells. Goodluck!

5. Love stories in Pinoy reality TV are blech.

Oh. Please. No more love angles.

6. Jeff Probst = Survivor.

I have nothing against Paolo Bediones. But there’s only one Survivor host in my book. No one can smell controversy and tribal conflicts better than Probst. He can turn things around if he wants to.

If it were any other shows, Paolo might do justice. But this is not the Miss Universe beauty pageant or some cheesy game show after all.

The only advantage Pinoys have in Survivor is that they can EAT anything. Grubs, worms, spiders, you name it. Nobody can stand in the way of a hungry Pinoy, that’s for sure.

Advertisements

~ by Mitch on August 26, 2008.

5 Responses to “BIRTHDAYS AND WHY SURVIVOR PHILS. MIGHT NOT WORK FOR US”

  1. feeling ata ni paolo bediones porke’t nag-host sha ng reality games shows eh kaya na niya tapatan ang survivor. let’s wait and see. hehe 😀

  2. mitch where have you been? nag-start na yung Survivor Philippines di ka pa nag-update ng blog. hehehe.. kapuso ako pero i’m gonna say this: irritating mag host si Paolo Bediones sa Survivor Philippines. so far, mas aabangan ko pa si Arnold Clavio at Vicky Morales kaysa makulili ang tenga ko kay Paolo. mas bagay sya sa Extra Challenge. :p

  3. @aajao: Oo nga e! Hahaha! Sorry naman. I’ve been really busy e. 😛 Anyway, I haven’t watched an episode but I’m looking forward to watching the first tribal council.

    Altho, yeah, may mga nagsasabing parang Extra Challenge daw. Wag naman sana. @_@

  4. Hi! I’m new here. I was just browsing through d net to look for Survivor Phils blogs. I’m a big fan of d original Survivor. I couldn’t agree with you more with your insights. I especially agree with points 4, 5, and 6.

    I really don’t know where to begin. Have you watched the show? My God! Sinayang nila ang franchise ng Survivor!!! San ka nakakita ng dramahan within an immunity challenge. Para lang maging araw araw ang show e sobrang nilang pinapatagal ang mga kadramahan. it’s not exciting anymore to watch. I don’t think GMA is a rating monger. it’s more a money monger!

    hay, basta!!!! i really hate the show!!!! the editing is not good!!! paolo bediones is irritating!!! the castaways are not exciting!!!! plus they don’t look like they are being challenged. they look like they are being pampered. it looks like they are just having a vacation in thailand!!! this show is a waste of time!!!!

    watch the second week immunity challenge where nag-agawan sila ng Thai pillows. did the producers, writers, editors, and staff even watched the original show?!!! i mean what was that shit?!!! i know they may be aiming for originality or something, pero in a show like Survivor, excitement is the key. if you lose the excitement, you lose people, and i think they achieved that.

    the OBB!!! what was that?!!! it’s not exciting. it’s bland!!!!

    my friends who watch the original Survivor are not watching Survivor Philippines. And i tell them they are not missing a thing. Survivor Philippines is just a waste of time.

    abangan nalang natin ang Survivor: Gabon. sana makita nila how Survivor should be done.

    mas kaabang-abang pa nga ata ang Pinoy Fear Factor eh. sometimes i wonder how come GMA claims they’re #1 when they are producing lame shows like Survivor Philippines?!

    there… nakapaglabas na ako ng sama ng loob ko. actually, d pa yan lahat. marami pa akong gustong sabihin kaya lang nakakapagod. Sayang na Sayang lang sabi nga ni Manilyn Reynes. Binaboy ng GMA ang franchise like what they did with Idol, Celebrity Duets, and Are You Smarter Than a Fifth Grader. Baka pati Family Feud e babuyin din nila. My God!

  5. Hi Ruzztye!

    Easy ka lang. 😛

    I was able to watch just one episode (LOL) although I read forums and transcripts of the show. Di kasi ako matiyaga sa araw-araw e.

    I find the show okay, although may mga weak points talaga. And I still don’t feel Paolo Bediones as the host. The characters were alright. No one is outstanding yet. And full of drama na agad, 2 tribal councils pa lang. 😀

    There are fans of the original Survivor who do and don’t like Survivor Philippines. For me naman, I’m just one of those who are curious as to how it would play out. Iba talaga kasi kapag Pinoy talaga yung characters. I’ve always imagined our very own version of the show and finally, meron na.

    About the ratings/money mongering, it’s really pointless to try to have the network not think about it so much. Because it’s all they think about. All networks do diba? Whatever they decide to do, it’s up to us whether we invest time over it or not.

    Btw, Gabon was exciting already, the first two episodes. 😉 Two very deserving boots.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: